Nov 21, 2026
It was another bluebird day in mid-November here in Central Vermont, so I hopped on the Tracker and headed out to Pine Hill Park for an afternoon ride that unfortunately was interrupted by a mechanical that forced me to walk home.
Riding the two miles from the house, I noticed the parking lot at Giorgetti Park was completely packed. Cars—mostly sporting bike racks—were spilling out onto the side of Oak Street Extension, likely a mix of trail riders and a hockey game going on at the arena. I rolled up to the trailhead, fired up Trailforks on my watch, and headed into the woods.
As soon as I started climbing, my shifting started acting up again. I thought I had dialed it in after my last ride, and it had been fine in the highest gears on the pavement over. Once I hit the dirt, it worked fine in my two lowest climbing gears, too—it was just everything in between that was skipping.
At the top of Furlough, I passed a sizable group of riders chatting; it was easily the biggest crowd I’ve ever seen gathered at an intersection in the park. My goal was to ride the Redfield Trails out to the overlook, so I kept climbing up Rembrandt's Brush. Things were rolling smoothly enough despite the finicky shifting, and I started wondering if my derailleur hanger was bent. I made a mental note to swing by the bike shop on my way home to have them check it out.
Right on cue, my chain made a horrible crunching sound and dropped off the front chainring—no small feat considering I run a front chain guide.
I dismounted to put it back on and immediately saw the culprit: one of the links was coming apart. I reached into my frame bag and pulled out my Crankbrothers multi-tool, which has a built-in chain breaker. I managed to pry the busted outer plate off the inner link and tried using the tool to push the pin out far enough to remove the damaged section and reconnect the chain. No luck. The tool just wouldn't push the pin far enough to free the inner link. I was officially stuck.
I stashed the broken chain in my bag, turned around, and coasted back down the trail, pushing the bike up the flats and short climbs until I finally reached the trailhead.
I checked the public repair stand hoping for a heavier-duty chain tool, but came up empty. I asked a few folks in the parking lot who had bikes racked on their cars, and while one woman near the entrance did have a chain tool, it was the exact same Crankbrothers multi-tool I had. Knowing that was a dead end, I started the long trek home.
After a mix of coasting and walking down the River Trail, I turned onto West Street toward downtown. Just as I crossed the railroad tracks, it dawned on me that Down Valley Bikes would still be open, so I walked the bike over.
Scott was able to take a look right away. To bridge the missing section of chain, he would have had to use two quick links. That made me a little nervous, so I figured it was smarter to just put a brand-new chain on. Before we did that, though, I asked him to check the alignment of my derailleur hanger.
He threw the Tracker up on the stand and immediately spotted play right where the derailleur bolts to the hanger. He explained that it's a common issue on budget derailleurs—the bushing inside the mounting bolt wears out, leaving the whole unit unstable.
At that point, the decision was easy: let's replace the derailleur, too. He didn't have one in stock, so he ordered one that will be in next week. The silver lining? The new derailleur can handle a wider gear range. I'm currently running a 46t cassette in the rear, and the new setup will clear up to a 51t. Sounds like an upgrade might be in my future—and maybe I can swap that 46t over to my titanium bike.
Down Valley Bikes is a fantastic shop, and I can't recommend them enough if you need a repair or gear. They have great prices, an awesome lineup of bikes that I always end up drooling over, and their shop dog, Leiah—a German Shepherd who might give you a bark at the door, turns into the sweetest pup once she gets knows you.
In the end, my "walk of shame" turned out to be pretty serendipitous. A busted chain forced me into the shop, which led to finally diagnosing the root cause of my shifting headaches. Chapeau to Scott at Down Valley for getting me sorted out!




No comments:
Post a Comment